Teaching Kids About Logical Fallacies
Stephanie Simoes is the founder of Critikid, a critical thinking and media literacy education site for kids and teens.
Learning about logical fallacies helps kids evaluate arguments more carefully and think more clearly about their own reasoning. Even fairly abstract logical fallacies can be accessible to kids when they’re taught through concrete, relatable examples. In this post, I’ll explain why logical fallacies are worth teaching and suggest some practical ways to introduce them to kids.
When we talk with children about logical fallacies, we equip them to recognize when convincing-sounding reasoning is flawed. Faulty reasoning may sometimes be used deliberately to influence our beliefs and decisions. The goal is to be able to evaluate arguments more carefully so that we become less susceptible to manipulation.
For example, a child might feel pressured by a classmate who says, “Either you’ll let me cheat off you or you’re not a good friend.” But a child who understands false dilemmas knows that these are not the only two possibilities. They can refuse to help their classmate cheat and still be a good friend. Learning about fallacies at a young age also prepares children to recognize the manipulative tactics they will encounter in advertising throughout their lives.
Children also need to recognize fallacies in their own thought processes. For example, when a rumour spreads around a school, a child may think, “Everyone’s saying it, so it must be true.” Students who have learned about the bandwagon fallacy know that a lot of people saying something doesn’t tell us that it’s true. Or a child might think, “I don’t have time to complete a full practice session, so there’s no point practicing it at all.” But a child who knows about the nirvana fallacy recognizes that we shouldn’t reject beneficial options just because they fall short of an ideal.
One of the best ways I’ve found to teach fallacies is through stories because they make these abstract concepts concrete and relatable. The stories can be a simple dialogue or a short story. Here is a story that I wrote to teach kids about the sunk cost fallacy:
Beachtown is experiencing serious beach erosion. In other words, it is losing lots of sand!
The mayor of Beachtown asks scientists to develop a chemical reaction to make sand quickly. The scientists say, “This will be very difficult, maybe impossible.”
The mayor replies, “Just try. I will give you $1 million for the research.”
One year later, the scientists report, “We have spent all the money and we have not been able to find a chemical reaction to make sand fast. We are even more certain that it is not possible now.”
The mayor replies, “The money I spent on this project would be wasted if you don’t succeed. Take another $1 million and keep trying.”
Another year passes, and the scientists are no closer to finding a solution. “We can’t give you what you are looking for,” they say. “You need to find another way to protect the beaches.”
The mayor thinks, “If they fail, it means I have wasted $2 million of the town’s money. They must succeed.” She gives the scientists another $1 million and tells them to carry on.
After reading this story, I ask children if the mayor was right or wrong to give the scientists more money, and why or why not. Next, I ask them to write their own short stories or dialogues that contain the fallacy. Creating their own examples helps deepen and reinforce their understanding of how the fallacy works and makes the flawed reasoning pattern easier to remember. It is also helpful to connect the lessons to their own lives. For example, you can ask where they might encounter this kind of reasoning in advertising, arguments with friends, or online discussions.
Teenagers who use social media can be challenged to look for logical fallacies in their feeds. They may notice the appeal to nature fallacy (assuming that “natural” things are better or healthier than “unnatural” ones) in advertisements or the straw man fallacy (misrepresenting someone’s position to make it easier to rebut) in comment section arguments. For children who are too young to use social media independently, adults can scroll together with them and discus the fallacies they notice.
I built a Social Media Simulator for anyone who wants to teach these skills without exposing children to real social media yet. It gives children a safe, controlled space to practice spotting common logical fallacies and other problematic posts.
Be aware, however, that once kids learn about logical fallacies, they may become very enthusiastic about spotting them and start labelling arguments as fallacious simply because they resemble a familiar fallacy. But since context matters for informal fallacies, arguments that look like fallacies are not always fallacious.
For example, insulting someone is not necessarily an ad hominem fallacy. It is a fallacy when the personal attack is used as a reason to undermine the other person’s argument. But if the insult merely accompanies a rebuttal and is not being used as evidence against the claim, it may be rude, but it is not a logical fallacy. Because of this, it’s important to teach each fallacy with both genuine examples and similar-looking arguments that are not actually fallacious.
As well, we should not teach kids to hunt for fallacies simply so they can dismiss other people’s arguments or feel that they’ve won a debate. The goal is to help them recognize when others are using faulty reasoning to mislead or manipulate them, examine their own reasoning more carefully, and make more thoughtful decisions.
I’ve written more about the potential problems with teaching fallacies in my article How Teaching Logical Fallacies Can Backfire.