Ethics Case Library

This library includes cases written for the Middle School Ethics Bowl since 2019 and cases written by middle school and high school students as part of the Ethics Case Writing Project. These cases can be used in classrooms and other ethics forums.

Any middle school or high school student from anywhere in the world can help build the library by submitting a case. For more information, see the Ethics Case Submission Guidelines tab on the Questions page.

The cases are listed alphabetically by title. You can search for cases by year, keyword, and grade level.

(Adopting) A Dog’s Purpose
2020 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Animal ethics, Community obligations
View Ethics Case
A Hoodwink and a Nudge?
2020 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Marketing, Utilitarianism
View Ethics Case
Accommodations on Board: Are They a Moral Obligation?
2025
Valerie Wang, age 14, Liberal Arts and Science Academy, Austin, Texas
Accomodations, Community obligations, Duty
View Ethics Case
AI in College Admissions: Algorithmic Acceptance?
2025
Robert Wei, age 16, Princeton Day School, Princeton, New Jersey
AI, College admissions, Education, Technology
View Ethics Case
AI, Friend or Foe?
2026 – Middle School
MSEB Case
AI, Friendship
View Ethics Case
Ambiguous AI Art
2023 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Aesthetics, AI, Ownership
View Ethics Case
Appearances at the Office
2020 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Gender inequality, Immigration, Workplaces
View Ethics Case
Are Private Schools Inherently Unethical?
2023
Melina Mickelson, age 14, Cleveland STEM High School, Seattle, Washington
Education, Parental rights, School ethics
View Ethics Case
Artists and Their Political Views
2024
Aliya Muhametzanova, age 14, Gymnasium No. 175, Kazan, Republic of Tatarstan, Russia
Art, Entertainment, Freedom of speech, Motivation, Music, Politics, Social responsibility
View Ethics Case
Assessing the Ethics of Group Projects
2024
Seryeong Jo, Kate Allison, Klair Allision, ages 17, TMI Episcopal School, San Antonio, Texas
Community obligations, Duty, Education, Fairness
View Ethics Case
Balancing Safety and Privacy: Parental Access to Children’s Social Media Accounts
2024
Madison Shen, age 14, Harvard-Westlake School, San Marino, California
Parental rights, Privacy, Social media
View Ethics Case
Behind the Bikini: Who’s Accountable?
2025 – High School
Avery Mangan and Sara Pierre, age 18, Allen D. Nease High School, Ponte Vedra, Florida
Community obligations, Entertainment, Mental health, Relationships, Social media
View Ethics Case
Believing in Others
2020 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Careers, Friendship, Honesty, Professional ethics
View Ethics Case
Best Man or Worst Man?
2021 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Friendship, Honesty
View Ethics Case
Capitalizing on Capital Crime
2024 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Justice, Utilitarianism, Victim rights
View Ethics Case
Career Choice
2022 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Altruism, Careers, Environmental ethics
View Ethics Case
Cash Incentives
2022 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Duty, Incentive programs, Kantian ethics, Marketing, Workplaces
View Ethics Case
Choices in the Workplace
2022 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Careers, Community obligations, Duty, Family, Honesty, Professional ethics, Workplaces
View Ethics Case
Concert Conflict
2025 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Freedom of speech, Friendship, Hate speech, Music, Social responsibility
View Ethics Case
Data Collection Ethics
2024
Shawn Zhu, age 16, Downingtown STEM Academy, Downingtown, Pennsylvania
Privacy, Technology
View Ethics Case
Dear Diary
2020 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Friendship, Honesty, Privacy, Relationships
View Ethics Case
Dear Grandma
2025 – Middle School
MSEB Case
AI, Authenticity, Family, Relationships
View Ethics Case
Defacing Art as a Form of Protest
2023
Claire Cherrill, age 15, Kent Place School, Summit, New Jersey
Art, Environmental ethics, Politics
View Ethics Case
Desk Rent
2020 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Economics, Education, Justice
View Ethics Case
Dining Out During a Pandemic
2021 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Pandemic, Public health, Social responsibility
View Ethics Case
Donation Dilemma
2023 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Altruism, Social responsibility
View Ethics Case
Ethics Bowl vs. Prom
2021 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Community obligations, Loyalty
View Ethics Case
Ethnolinguistic Nationality
2025 – High School
Kieran Batchelli-Hennessey, age 16, Sacred Heart Cathedral Preparatory, San Francisco, California
Nationality, Politics
View Ethics Case
Evaluating Historical Figures Through a Contemporary Lens
2023
Joonyoung Heo, age 16, Phillips Exeter Academy, Exeter, New Hampshire
Authenticity, History, Value of human beings
View Ethics Case
Fake Followers
2020 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Consumerism, Social media
View Ethics Case
Family Spies
2020 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Family, Privacy, Safety, Technology
View Ethics Case
Farmer’s Market Fisticuffs
2024 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Animal ethics, Consumerism, Economics
View Ethics Case
Freedom of Tweet
2023 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Freedom of speech, Hate speech, Social media
View Ethics Case
Friendship Ties
2023 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Friendship, Loyalty, Relationships, Social responsibility
View Ethics Case
Honesty v. Loyalty Among Friends
2023
Sophia Galova, age 18, Langley High School, Langley, Virginia
Community obligations, Friendship, Honesty, Integrity, Loyalty, Relationships
View Ethics Case
How Public is Public Land?
2024
Bella Welch, age 18, Ingraham High School, Seattle, Washington
Fairness, History, Integrity, Ownership, Public land
View Ethics Case
In it for the Likes
2020 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Altruism, Authenticity, Motivation, Social media, Virtue ethics
View Ethics Case
Informed Consent in Survey Research
2023 – High School
Daliya Rizvi, age 18, Langley High School, Langley, Virginia
Anonymity, Consent, Privacy, School ethics
View Ethics Case
Internet Use at School
2023 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Education, Mental health, Privacy, School ethics, Surveillance
View Ethics Case
Is Euthanasia Ethical?
2023 – High School
Mason Cheng, age 17, American Heritage Broward, Plantation, Florida
Autonomy, Death, Mental health, Public health
View Ethics Case
Is it Beneficial for Teachers to be Armed in School?
2024 – High School
Tovah Leathersich, age 15, Uwharrie Charter School, Asheboro, North Carolina
Gun violence, Safety, School ethics
View Ethics Case
Is Note-Sharing in Class Unethical?
2024
Crichton Rockwell, age 14, The Harker School, Los Gatos, California
Education, Honesty, Integrity, Ownership, Privacy, School ethics
View Ethics Case
Is Social Media a Good or Bad Thing?
2024
Yu-Ming Liu, age 16, Henry M. Gunn High School, Palo Alto, California
Community obligations, Mental health, Social media, Technology
View Ethics Case
Like, Study, and Share?
2026 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Authenticity, Finances, Marketing, Social media, Social responsibility
View Ethics Case
Lock boxes in Schools: Solution to Cellphone Distraction or Infringement on Autonomy?
2025
Charles Lugo, age 15, Staples High School, Westport, Connecticut
Education, Safety, School ethics, Student behavior, Technology
View Ethics Case
Meat Without Harm?
2025 – High School
Ayushi Wadhwa, age 15, Kent Place School, Summit, New Jersey
Animal ethics, Food ethics, Technology
View Ethics Case
Nandi’s Choice
2021 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Family, Social responsibility, Tradition
View Ethics Case
No More Teachers, No More Books
2021 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Education, Pandemic, Public health, Utilitarianism
View Ethics Case
Number on the Scale
2025 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Body image, Fairness, Mental health, School ethics, Sports ethics
View Ethics Case
Paying for High Test Scores
2020 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Education, Equity, Motivation
View Ethics Case
Philharmonic or Fun?
2026 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Education, Equity, Fairness, School ethics
View Ethics Case
Photoshop Fiction
2022 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Authenticity, Body image, Photography ethics
View Ethics Case
Prayers for Peers
2025 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Pluralism, Religion, School ethics
View Ethics Case
Relying on Civilian Intelligence in the Russo-Ukrainian War
2023
Zachary Lin, age 17, Huron High School, Ann Arbor, Michigan
Military ethics, War
View Ethics Case
Respect for the Dead: Displaying Human Remains in a Museum
2023
AKW, age 16, Ballard High School, Seattle, Washington
Bioethics, Consent, Museum ethics
View Ethics Case
Returning History: The Ethics of Artifact Repatriation
2025 – High School
Juley Guan, age 16, American Heritage Broward, Plantation, Florida
Art, Colonialism, Museum ethics, Ownership
View Ethics Case
Revenge in Major League Baseball: Should MLB Issue Harsh Penalties for Beaning Batters?
2024
Niall Rubin, age 12, Woodstock Union, Woodstock, Vermont
Justice, Sports ethics, Vigilantism
View Ethics Case
Running in Ramadan
2024 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Community obligations, Pluralism, Virtue ethics
View Ethics Case
School Transfer
2022 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Friendship, Honesty, Integrity
View Ethics Case
Science Unfair
2021 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Honesty, Integrity, School ethics
View Ethics Case
Scroll, Swipe, Sleep?
2025
Lakshya Yadav, age 17 and Aarush Reddy Vurady, age17, Allen D. Nease High School, Saint Johns, Florida
Addiction, Mental health, Social media, Student behavior, Technology
View Ethics Case
Should Artists’ Ethics Affect Our Artistic Judgments?
2023 – High School
Nikki Gao, age 16, Academy at Palumbo, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Aesthetics, Art, Gender inequality
View Ethics Case
Should Developing Countries Prioritize Economic Growth or Environmental Preservation?
2025
Suvid Bordia, age 15, The Pingry School, Short Hills, New Jersey
Development ethics, Environmental ethics, Sustainability
View Ethics Case
Should Influencers be Sponsored by Businesses
2025
Valerie Wang, age 14, Liberal Arts and Science Academy, Austin, Texas
Integrity, Social media, Technology
View Ethics Case
Should Judges Be Active on Social Media?
2024
Impartiality, Professional ethics, Social media
View Ethics Case
Should Science Media Have Political Stances?
2024
Emma Zhang, age 17, Branham High School, San Jose, California, USA
Impartiality, Politics, Science ethics
View Ethics Case
Should the Military Recruit in Schools?
2023
AKW, age 16, Ballard High School, Seattle, Washington
Autonomy, Military ethics, School ethics
View Ethics Case
Should We Watch True Crime Dramas?
2023 – High School
Claire Cherrill, age 15, Kent Place School, Summit, New Jersey
Entertainment, Fairness, Injustice, Representation, Virtue ethics
View Ethics Case
Summer Engagements
2024 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Family, Integrity, Virtue ethics
View Ethics Case
The Benefits and Harms of Gene Editing
2023
Prudence Frein, age 16, Haverford High School, Havertown, Pennsylvania
Bioethics, Public health, Technology
View Ethics Case
The Case of the Missing Serial Number
2021 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Honesty, Integrity, Virtue ethics
View Ethics Case
The Dress Dilemma
2023 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Consumerism, Equity, Finances, Social responsibility, Virtue ethics
View Ethics Case
The Ethics of a Cashless Society
2024
Sammy Lou, age 17, Trinity Preparatory School, Winter Park, Florida
Equity, Fairness, Justice, Technology
View Ethics Case
The Ethics of AI in Warfare
2025 – High School
Agnut Asfir, age 17, River Islands High School, Lathrop, California
AI, Military ethics, Professional ethics, Technology, War
View Ethics Case
The Ethics of Fast Fashion
2025
Henry Russell, age 14, Tandem Friends School, Charlottesville, Virginia
Consumerism, Environmental ethics, Fast fashion
View Ethics Case
The Ethics of Favoring Donor Families in College Admissions
2024
Sehwan Park, age 17, Saint Paul Preparatory, Seoul, Republic of Korea
College admissions, Discrimination, Education, Equity, Impartiality
View Ethics Case
The Ethics of Private College Advisors
2024
Chloe Archibald, age 15, Ramaz Upper School, New York, New York
College admissions, Education, Equity
View Ethics Case
The Ethics of Tipping
2023
Mason Cheng, age 17, American Heritage, Plantation, Florida
Consumerism, Fairness, Finances, Tipping
View Ethics Case
The Ethics of Unintentional Wrongs
2025
Keane Miller, age 12, The Evergreen School, Shoreline, Washington
Bystanders, Community obligations, Loyalty, Offensive jokes
View Ethics Case
The Ethics of Using Facial Recognition Technology
2023
Jennifer Tang, age 15, Huron High School, Ann Arbor, Michigan
Discrimination, Privacy, Surveillance, Technology
View Ethics Case
The Face of the Future
2026 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Bias, Equity, Social responsibility
View Ethics Case
The Final Semester
2026 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Honesty, Inappropriate videos, School ethics, Student behavior
View Ethics Case
The Invasive Species Plan
2025 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Animal ethics, Environmental ethics, Utilitarianism
View Ethics Case
The Mischarging Mishap
2022 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Error in your favor, Honesty, Local businesses
View Ethics Case
The Scarce Resource
2024 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Public health, Utilitarianism, Value of human beings
View Ethics Case
Throwing Stones at a Plastic House
2025 – High School
Lily Simmer, age 17 and Sanjana Kamalraj, age 17, Allen D. Nease High School, Ponte Vedra, Florida
Social media, Social responsibility
View Ethics Case
To Persevere or To Pass
2025 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Friendship, Honesty, Student behavior
View Ethics Case
Using AI in the Classroom
2023
Avi Skuben, age 13, Astra Nova School
AI, Education, Equity, School ethics, Technology
View Ethics Case
Web Proxies in Schools
2024
Julien Bryzek, age 15, Bergen County Technical High School, Teterboro, New Jersey
Education, Equity, School ethics, Technology
View Ethics Case
Who Gets to be Fashionable?
2021 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Fast fashion
View Ethics Case
Wool and Leather
2020 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Animal ethics
View Ethics Case
You Can’t Change That!
2020 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Heckling, Sports ethics
View Ethics Case
Zero Days
2024 – Middle School
MSEB Case
Ends versus means, Privacy, Surveillance
View Ethics Case